Differences And Similarities Between Frankenstein 1931... (2025)

Better Essays

Open Document

Differences And Similarities Between Frankenstein 1931 And 1994

View Writing Issues

958 Words

Grammar

Plagiarism

Writing

Score

Differences And Similarities Between Frankenstein 1931 And 1994

“Comparison of themes from two movies”
Frankenstein 1931 and Frankenstein 1994 For my final essay I chose to compare main themes from movies Frankenstein, released in different periods. First one is from the year 1931 and the other one is from 1994. Both are based on Mary Shelley’s novel “Frankenstein or; The Modern Prometheus”, from 1818. The storyline is generally the same in both movies, but themes differ, due to different release periods. The story is about a scientist, dr. Frankenstein, who dreams of creating artificial life from dead tissue. The creature he creates becomes alive, but is not accepted neither from him, nor from the society, which leads it to become evil and dangerous. The two movies differently deal with the relationship …show more content…
between the creature and the scientist, and also the creature is in my opinion differently portrayed in each movie, which effects the viewer and his or hers opinion and feelings towards it. In the centre is the idea of a gentle creature being mistaken for a monster. I will analyze different themes and also mention what is the role of science in the mentioned movies. I will begin with the movie from 1931.
The main theme is religion. In the beginning, the narrator introduces the theme of creation relating that Dr. Frankenstein wants to create a man after his own image. He wants to destroy and then recreate human life. He thinks he is God, and when the monster moves its hand, he says: “Now I know what it feels like to be God.” It is about god-like power and immortality. At the time when this movie was made, science was still seen by most of the American public as a dangerous philosophy rather than as a rational discipline. It was considered to be a defying divine provenance (mad scientists were always defying taboo areas – attempting to raise the dead, to prolong youth, and so on). In this version there is a wonderful sense of …show more content…
innocence to the monster, a dumb brute with the heart of a child. It does not speak, think, or understand what is right and what is wrong, which makes his violent behavior easier to justify. The movie portrays a society with a rigid set of behavior, values and roles, such as when evil lurks, women hide, but men conquer over evil. In this version of the movie, relationship between the monster and its creator is not that explicit, whereas in the 1994 version, it is very vividly portrayed. I like the movie from 1994 better, because it explores character’s relationships.
There are two themes that I consider as worth mentioning. First is the monster’s pitiable and tormented existence, which is caused by Frankenstein’s disregard for the consequences of the things he does. Doctor cares only for himself, puts his experiments before his fiancé, and later when the monster kills her, he brings her back to life, regardless of her feelings on the matter. Second theme is a love theme between Elizabeth and Victor Frankenstein. His seemingly lunatic experiments turn out to be all for the sake of one belief which is that people deserve to live out their lives in the company of those they love. In this movie, the creature is treated like a person, not a monster. It is extremely intelligent and is fully aware of its cruelty. It turns to evil because of its complete rejection by society, not because of a defective brain like in the first movie. The creature only wants a friend, someone who would love it. For the sympathy of one living being it is prepared to make peace with all the rest. Doctor Frankenstein and his creation have an odd, sophisticated and complex relationship. The creature says: “You gave me these emotions, but you did not tell me how to use them.” That kind of dialogues and the way that the creature thinks made me feel sad and sorry for it. It wanted Frankenstein to be its father, to teach it how to live a life, but he did not do that. Towards the end the
creature wants to find its creator and kill him, but when they confront each other, it says right the opposite. It wants to know what kind of people it is made of. Good or bad? Who is he? But doctor does not know how to answer these questions. This film is very emotional, at least for me, because I felt sorry for the creature. I think that doctor’s creation is much more human than other people are, including the doctor. When doctor dies, the creature weeps at his bedside and says that he never gave it a name. This was again an emotional and sad scene.
Frankenstein is considered as horror, science fiction, some even say it is autobiography (Mary had a desire for a stable family, which is why many have stated that the novel is autobiographical in many aspects). With this movie, a new genre was introduced to the public, and people were terrified in a good way. Horror of the 1930s and 40s regarded science as something dangerous that could overturn the fragile balance of society and that the world was better off not knowing about these things. The story might have brought chills to the 19th century viewers, but it is pretty tame in the 21st. The ideas that the 1994 movie remake outs forward are not that radical anymore (it was not focused on the intense dark characters and intriguing story, but more on the production design, make-up and costumes), but still for me, this version of the movie was more catchy and compelling because of the emotions that it brings up inside of you, when you are watching it.

View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

Good Essays
Comparing Frankenstein 'And Blade Runner'
- 480 Words
- 2 Pages
Comparing Frankenstein 'And Blade Runner'

In comparing the treatment of the myriad of enduring issues and concepts explored in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818) and Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner (1982), the influence of their vastly different contexts is impossible to overlook.…
- 480 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Comparison of Frankenstein and Blade Runner
- 778 Words
- 4 Pages
Comparison of Frankenstein and Blade Runner

Though composed at different times, the themes portrayed in both Frankenstein and Blade Runner are evidently influenced by their own respective contexts – the early 19th century and late 20th century. These texts put forward an exploration of humanity and morality, the value of nature as well as individualism as these themes and values are perceived in each context.…
- 778 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Exploration of a Wide Range of Themes Concerning Human Nature in mary Shelley's Frankenstein
- 702 Words
- 3 Pages
Exploration of a Wide Range of Themes Concerning Human Nature in mary Shelley's Frankenstein

In her novel Frankenstein, Mary Shelley explores a wide range of themes concerning human nature through the thoughts and actions of two main characters and a host of others. Two themes are at the heart of the story, the most important being creation, but emphasis is also placed on alienation from society. These two themes are relevant even in today's society as technology brings us ever closer to Frankenstein's fictional achievement.…
- 702 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Frankenstein and Blade Runner Comparative Study
- 1034 Words
- 5 Pages
Frankenstein and Blade Runner Comparative Study

In what ways does a comparative study accentuate the distinctive contexts of Frankenstein and Blade Runner:…
- 1034 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Comparing Frankenstein And Blade Runner
- 1093 Words
- 5 Pages
Comparing Frankenstein And Blade Runner

Analyse how Frankenstein and Blade Runner imaginatively portray individuals who challenge the established values of their time…
- 1093 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Outline For Frankenstein Research Paper
- 502 Words
- 3 Pages
Outline For Frankenstein Research Paper

The creature in Frankenstein is banished by De Lacy, Felix Lacy, Agatha Lacy, and Safie. The creature lives in a room next to theirs and watches them. He subtly helps them and is quite kind, but when he reveals himself they chase him away and beat him. "I do know that for the sympathy of one living being, I would make peace with all. I have love in me the likes of which you can scarcely imagine and rage the likes of which you would not believe. If I cannot satisfy the one, I will indulge the other." This is a quote by the monster showing that he is rejected by almost every person he comes in contact with in the book. The monster begins to act out after constantly being rejected and starts to kill Victor’s loved ones for…
- 502 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Better Essays
Comparing Frankenstein 'And The Creature'
- 1421 Words
- 6 Pages
Comparing Frankenstein 'And The Creature'

The Romantic era took place throughout the 19th century and held the belief that men demonstrate innate goodness, but civilization later corrupts them. Even in today’s society, many political figures, authors, celebrities, and athletes reinforce the Romantic idea of the natural goodness of man and the corruption of man by civilization as they initially exhibit pure values that succumb to the temptations civilization provides. Literature also reflects the belief of the innate goodness of man and the corruption of man by society. For example, Mary Shelley, entails these Romantic beliefs in her novel Frankenstein, in which both Victor Frankenstein and the Creature are born innately good but society later corrupts them. Victor’s,…
- 1421 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Who Is Responsible In Frankenstein
- 551 Words
- 3 Pages
Who Is Responsible In Frankenstein

It is here where the creature tells of his true nature. He is a being only wanting sympathy and compassion not unlike the wanting of most men. When he first meets people in a village he is immediately hated. He does not yet understand why and wishes only for the friendship and understanding. His next attempt is with a family living in a small cottage near the woodlands of which the monster resides. Learning from his previous encounter with the village people he waits months to attempt speaking to the cottagers. When he does he is only accepted by the blind father, but this joy is short lived by the creature for the son of the man immediately upon his return to the cottage throws the being out in an attempt to “save” their father from the retched beast. It is here after that the beast learns that the only being he can gain sympathy from would be one of his own species, however, only his creator can make him a companion. Frankenstein firstly agrees to the task only to realize what this would mean to the world and destroys his work before it is finished. This is the final blow the monster and he becomes ever more so blood…
- 551 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Victor And Frankenstein Comparison Essay
- 998 Words
- 4 Pages
Victor And Frankenstein Comparison Essay

In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, Victor Frankenstein and the monster that he creates are very similar. Frankenstein being a great man had his wants and needs even though he studied things that people thought to be ungodly and just wrong. Frankenstein creates the monster to be like himself although the monster has super human strength and is almost eight feet tall. Victor worked very hard trying to create the monster not noticing that he was creating the monster in his image.…
- 998 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Examples Of Nurture In Frankenstein
- 851 Words
- 4 Pages
Examples Of Nurture In Frankenstein

Three events led to the creature’s turning point at which he started doing evil things. He was completely rejected by society when the DeLaceys chased him away, when [they] shot him after he saved a girl from downing, and when he discovered Victor Frankenstein’s papers describing his disgust in his creation. These overwhelmingly negative experiences led the creature to commit evil deeds. He was angered that he was forced to live an isolated life, even by his own creator. The creature was driven to murder Victor Frankenstein’s closest family and friends because of his immense…
- 851 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Better Essays
Compare And Contrast Victor Frankenstein
- 2080 Words
- 9 Pages
Compare And Contrast Victor Frankenstein

creation is brought to life he doesn’t like what he sees considering his creation to be a…
- 2080 Words
- 9 Pages
Better Essays

Read More
Powerful Essays
Sympathy In Frankenstein
- 2094 Words
- 9 Pages
Sympathy In Frankenstein

Frankenstein, written by Mary Shelley and first published in 1818, follows the set of extraordinary events encompassing the life of Victor Frankenstein; natural philosophy devotee and reanimation pioneer. Characterization plays a major role in encouraging different attitudes in Frankenstein, an example being how the reader is encouraged to feel sympathy for Frankenstein and his creation throughout the novel. Aided by the differing narrative perspective, these sympathies are continually evolving, changing as the reader’s perception of the two is altered, and at the end of the novel, the reader is left questioning who the real monster is: Frankenstein, or his creation? The…
- 2094 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Frankenstein
- 1894 Words
- 8 Pages
Frankenstein

The novel opens as Victor Frankenstein recalls his curiosity and fascination with human life. Frankenstein quickly becomes obsessed with experimenting, and he attempts to create a living being out of dead body parts. He succeeds, but his creation turns into a living monster. Exclaimed by Frankenstein, “It was the secrets of heaven and earth that I desired to learn” (Shelley 33). Victor is extremely horrified by his grotesque looking creation and falls into a severe illness. While Victor is ill, the monster escapes to the woods where he watches a family and tries to befriend the humans. But once the monster makes his presence known, the family can’t accept Frankenstein’s ugly appearance. Because all humans he encountered reject him, the monster begins to hate people and believe that they are his enemies. Frustrated, the monster returns to his creator and demands that Frankenstein makes a female companion to cure his loneliness. The creature promises Victor that he will leave with his female companion, travel to South America, and never come in contact with humans again. However, two years beforehand, the creature spitefully murdered Victor 's brother William to get back at him. Holding a grudge against his monster creation for the death of William, Victor refuses to make a friend for the monster. In an effort to make Victor as miserable as himself,…
- 1894 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Good Essays
Examples Of Injustice In Frankenstein
- 560 Words
- 3 Pages
Examples Of Injustice In Frankenstein

The creature created by Victor Frankenstein was very vicious and evil as described in the story. The book creates an image of the creature as a monster that murders people close to Victor. The monster is actually a victim of an injustice taking place. The creature understands that in his life there is no justice, he tries to make himself perfect in order to change his injustice, and the willingness of searching for fairness gives the story a sense of inspiration and life lessons.…
- 560 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays

Read More
Better Essays
Theme Of Individualism In Frankenstein
- 1555 Words
- 7 Pages
Theme Of Individualism In Frankenstein

The monster continually calls out for sensibility from the romantic. The monster has a desire for companionship, and implores of his creator to make him a being of his own species. The monster also desires to be accepted by mankind. The final way the monster displays sensibility is through his desire to learn. He displays his capabilities of learning at the beginning of his creation, and continues to grow throughout the novel. Victor Frankenstein shows the individualistic, mystic, and love of nature side of romanticism. He displays individualism through his desire to be his own creator. He also rejects the help from others, and strives on selfish ambition. Victor shows the mysticism, through gaining power of being his own god. Finally, he shows a love for nature, through taking the time to breathe and admire the beautiful countryside around him. Romanticism is concluded in the comparison of the two characters, and how similar their situations are. Victor Frankenstein and the monster both have a strong desire for love from others around them. They also show great passion for sympathy from others, which they do not necessarily receive. Their situations are unrealistic, and portray the case of non-neoclassicism. Both Frankenstein and the monster experience deep sorrow throughout the entire novel. This experience is heightened when the monster is denied a companion and Victor loses all of his loved ones. In the end, both Victor and the creature share their desire for friendship, which neither fully obtain, due to the circumstances of the rejection and bitterness. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, displays the aspects of Romanticism through Frankenstein and his creature; they display sensibility, individualism, love of nature, non-neoclassicism, and…
- 1555 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays

Read More

Differences And Similarities Between Frankenstein 1931... (2025)

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

Related Topics

References